I don’t agree with the MDQ being “Will
Jesse kill herself?” I believe that the question can be formed more
specifically to fit the plot of the play. The reason I believe the dramatic
question isn’t specific enough is because Jesse’s decision to kill herself
isn’t the main puzzle piece to the plot. Mother and Jesse have a long
conversation about the past including why Jesse has seizures, mother tells how
she never loved Jesse’s dad, and they both expose their deepest personal issues
they have trouble dealing with daily. All of these things seem to be what cause
Jesse to kill herself in the end. Even though the decision of Jesse killing
herself was introduced early, it wasn’t until later we found out her true
reasons for her actions. This is how I came to the question “Is the information
Mother tells Jesse going to cause Jesse to kill herself?”. The answer is “no”,
which is why the play continues. Jesse basically explains that the reason why
she plans to kill herself is because she didn’t become the person she thought
she would be, she was unhappy and alone. The reasons for her not becoming who
she thought she would be is because her mother with held information from her
about her health and her mother set her up with Cecil, the husband that left
her. I believe Jesse felt that she had no purpose and the long truthful
conversation she had with her mother just pushed her over the edge. Ultimately, Jesse’s suicide was a culmination of things not just her initial decision like
the original question suggests. My question allows for the other factors to be considered
before finding the answer to the dramatic question.
Although I agree with the points you've made about Jessie's reasons for ending her life, I think a more accurate MDQ may be "Will Mama accept Jessie's decision?". The play continues after the suicide and only ends when we see Mama finally start checking off Jessie's list, just as Jessie wanted Mama to.
ReplyDelete